After the 1962 debacle, the Kargil war is something even I could have managed better than the Generals, because I do play chess! In both games, strategy is more important than tactics.
In 1962, a fully prepared Chinese army, who knew every nook and corner of the locality, with the help of spies who mingled with Dalai Lama’s followers who fled to India, had amassed a huge force at the border. Our people did not have reliable maps and we could not understand their language.
What was considered a small incursion at the borders, was brought to the notice of Nehru. He casually wrote in the file: “Throw them out” and went to visit Ceylon.
Sardar Patel, Home Minister at that time, would have consulted all, including the army people, before deciding on the issue. He was a good administrator
Nehru was a good historian, writer and philosopher. Such people are good in a university, but unfit to hold administrative posts. It was Gandhi’s patently pro- Nehru stand and Machiavellian political manoeuvres, to eliminate all candidates, who may pose a threat to Nehru, that resulted in hoisting unworthy Nehru and thwarting the ablest politician Patel.
The area north of the Himalayan watershed, belongs to Tibet- ethnically, linguistically and geographically. The people can understand Tibetan language, but not Hindi. They look similar to their northerners. But for the formidable Brahmaputra river, Tibet would have conquered them. For them, Delhi and Lhasa are both alien.
The military establishment learned nothing from the defeat in 1962. When Pakistan infiltrated into Kargil and made bunkers there, we had no knowledge about it. A patrol party failed to come home. The commander of our forces dismissed it as of no consequence.
When it was finally discovered that they have a massive force at Kargil, the political establishment became panicky. The Bhartiya Janta Party was in power. They wanted to take it back as early as possible. The military wanted to encircle Kargil, for which they have to cross the line of control, demarcating the boundary; but the politicians forbade it. They knew that Gen. Musharuff will not hesitate even to use atom bombs which are under military control in Pakistan. (If we are afraid to use atom bombs, why make them, at such huge cost?)
So the military decided to attack from Indian side, knowing fully well that it is suicidal. Young officers who had just completed training, were asked to go and attack. It is like a game of chess, in which they have two rooks and a queen; we have only four pawns !
The hill was covered with snow and, in the moonlight, they could see the advance of our forces. When our forces came within range, they were all killed by enemy fire.
In the end, Bofors guns were used. This should have been done first. The best strategy would have been to wait indefinitely and go on bombarding them from the ground and air. The enemy would have fled; their aim of attacking Kashmir was just a dream.
A commanding officer who opposed the initial attack and made a written submission about it, was penalized. However, his paper could not be ignored. Now after eleven years, his stand has been vindicated and he has been reinstated.
The military establishment was recently rattled by the exposure of land scam, in which a top general was involved.
Like the political class, military is also incompetent and corrupt.
They are good at parades and march past, not in war.
Filed under: Uncategorized | Tagged: ALIEN, ARMY, ATOM BOMB, ATTACK, BOFORS GUN, BORDER, BOUNDARY, CEYLON, CHESS, CHINESE, COME HOME, CORRUPT, DALAI LAMA, DELHI, ENEMYY FIRE, FORCE, GAMES, GANDHI, GENERAL, GHOSTS, GOOD ADMINISTRATOR, HAUNT, HIMALAYAN WATERSHED, HISTORIAN, INCURSION, india, KARGIL, LANGUAGE, LHASA, LOCALITY, maps, MILITARY ESTABLISHMENT, MOONLIGHT, NEHRU, NOOK AND CORNER, PAKISTAN, PATEL, PATROL PARTY, PEOPLE, PHILSOPHER, POLITICAL CLASS, POLITICAL MANOEUVRES, SPIES, STRATEGY, TACTICS, UNFIT, UNIVERSITY, WAIT INDEFINITELY, WRITER | Leave a comment »
POEM – POETRY IS UNTRANSLATABLE
“I like the way your poem uses religious imagery to convey its meaning…very effective.” Comments a viewer.
It will be plagiarism, if I do not mention about the source of my two line poem. That is why I gave the Malayalam lines in bracket, I do not know the author.
Our language is very rich in what may be called poet philosophers.
N. Kumaran Asan is the topmost, among them, I think.
I do not know who wrote the lines which I have translated. The word “neethi” is much more than the word “truth”. It includes justice, humane nature etc. As I never attempted poetry, I was very much doubtful, whether I would be successful in translating it.
Martin’s opinion is very valuable.
Thank you, Martin.
Filed under: Uncategorized | Tagged: AUTHOR, BRACKET, COMMENTS, CONVEY MEANING, DOUBTFUL, HUMANE NATURE, JUSTICE, KUMARAN ASAN, LANGUAGE, MALAYALAM, MARTIN, MENTION SOURCE, NEETHI, OPINION, PLAGIARISM, POEM, POET PHILOSOPHERS, POETRY, RELIGIPOUS IMAGERY, SUCCESSFUL, TOPMOST, TRUTH, VALUABLETHANK YOU, VERY RICH, VIEWER, WAY | Leave a comment »